How we evaluate water tests and treatment systems
This page explains how we decide what to tell you about a water test or a treatment system. It applies to every guide, the results checker and the state testing pages. For who we are and how the site is funded, see About.
1. What we do and don't do
- We research and explain. We read official and academic sources, then organize what they say by contaminant, by test result and by treatment type.
- We do not run a laboratory or hands-on product tests, and we never present anyone's results as our own testing.
- We do not give medical advice or personal recommendations about a specific home. For any result over a health-based limit, we point you to your local or state health department, which CDC says can help you understand results and what to do next.[1]
2. Sources we use, in order of preference
| Source | What we use it for |
|---|---|
| U.S. EPA | Maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) and goals, secondary standards, health advisories, private well guidance, Consumer Confidence Reports, PFAS rule status[2][3][4][5][6][7] |
| U.S. CDC | What to test a private well for, and how often[1] |
| USGS | Water science definitions, such as hardness classes[8] |
| State health and environmental agencies | State rules, certified laboratory lists and testing programs; EPA lists each state's laboratory certification program[9] |
| University extension services | Practical guidance on testing and on which treatment fits which level[10][11] |
| NSF/ANSI standard descriptions | What a product certification does and does not cover[12] |
We do not use manufacturer or retailer marketing, forum posts, or AI-generated summaries as sources for facts. Every source is linked on the page where it is used, with the date we accessed it.
3. How we compare a test result with a limit
Lab results are compared with the type of reference value the source gives, and we always say which type it is:
- Maximum contaminant level (MCL): the highest level of a contaminant allowed in drinking water from public water systems; EPA describes MCLs as enforceable standards.[4]
- Maximum contaminant level goal (MCLG): the level below which there is no known or expected risk to health; EPA describes MCLGs as non-enforceable public health goals.[4]
- Action level / treatment technique: lead and copper are regulated by a treatment technique, with action levels that trigger additional steps for water systems.[2]
- Secondary standard (SMCL): non-enforceable guidelines for cosmetic and aesthetic effects such as taste, color, odor and staining.[3]
- Health advisory (HA): non-enforceable levels at which adverse health effects are not anticipated over a stated exposure time; EPA says they are subject to change.[4]
Private wells are not legally bound by these federal limits,[5] but they are the standard reference points health departments and extension services use, so we use them too. When a value is under review or a rule is changing, we state the status and date exactly as the source gives them. Units are converted only with a cited conversion (for example, about 17 mg/L per grain per gallon of hardness[11]).
4. How we match treatment to a result
We don't rank brands. We describe system types and the conditions under which a cited source says each type is a fit:
- Contaminant first. A system type is only listed for a contaminant if a cited source says it treats that contaminant.
- Level second. Where the source gives ranges (for example, iron or hydrogen sulfide concentrations that suit a particular filter), we organize the options by the measured level.[10][13]
- Water chemistry third. We include the conditions the source names, such as pH or dissolved oxygen, because they can rule a method in or out.[10]
- Certification check. We name the NSF/ANSI standard that applies to that system type (for example, NSF/ANSI 44 for softeners, 55 for UV, 58 for reverse osmosis) so you can check a specific product's listing. NSF notes that the standard numbers are not a ranking, and that a certification does not mean a system reduces all contaminants.[12]
- Retest. We recommend confirming any treatment with a follow-up lab test.
When two credible sources give different figures, we show both and name each, instead of quietly choosing one. Our rotten egg smell guide, for example, shows two agencies' different upper limits for one filter type.
5. Products, prices and affiliate links
- We never publish a price unless we checked it the same day, and we label it with the date checked.
- Any future product mention must state what it is certified for, verifiable on the certifier's listing.
- Commissions, if any, never change which system type a page recommends for a result. See the affiliate disclosure.
6. Review, updates and corrections
- Before publishing, every number is checked against the cited source's text and every link is checked.
- Each page shows a "last reviewed" date, and we periodically re-check older pages against their sources.
- Factual corrections are listed with dates on the corrections log. Report a problem through the contact page.
Sources
- Guidelines for Testing Well Water — U.S. CDC (accessed November 19, 2026)
- National Primary Drinking Water Regulations — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Secondary Drinking Water Standards: Guidance for Nuisance Chemicals — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Drinking Water Health Advisories (HAs) — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Private Drinking Water Wells — U.S. EPA (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Consumer Confidence Reports (CCR) — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS): Final PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Hardness of Water — U.S. Geological Survey Water Science School (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Contact Information for Certification Programs and Certified Laboratories for Drinking Water — U.S. EPA (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Iron and Manganese in Private Water Systems — Penn State Extension (accessed November 18, 2026)
- Water Softening — Penn State Extension (accessed November 18, 2026)
- NSF Standards for Water Treatment Systems — NSF (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Hydrogen Sulfide (Rotten Egg Odor) in Water Wells — Penn State Extension (accessed November 18, 2026)